Textile industry certificates more for show than safety

published 07-07-2015 10:39, last modified 07-07-2015 10:39
BSCI complaint on TÜV Rheinland’s audit report for Rana Plaza manufacturer

Certificates attesting to safety and working conditions in the textile industry are good for a corporation’s image but are of little use to those working in global production and supply chains. This was made all too clear by the collapse of the Rana Plaza factory complex in Dhaka, Bangladesh, which killed more than 1,130 people. German technical inspection company TÜV Rheinland audited the Phantom Apparel Ltd. production facilities just a few months before the catastrophe. The German certification company failed to address building safety and construction flaws and a number of other problems were not raised in its report. TÜV Rheinland was appointed as auditor by a member of the Business Social Compliance Initiative (BSCI). The BSCI is a corporate platform based in part on the standards of the International Labor Organization (ILO) and is supposed to monitor and improve safety and working conditions in production countries.

The European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights (ECCHR), FEMNET and the Clean Clothes Campaign (CCC), medico international and the Activist Anthropologist Collective from Bangladesh have submitted a joint complaint to the BSCI. The organizations are calling on the BSCI to disclose the audit contract as well as the reports on Rana Plaza by TÜV Rheinland and others and to overhaul the approach of inspection reports. “The certificates don’t tell us much. Consumers need to know exactly what is monitored,” says Miriam Saage-Maaß, head of the Business and Human Rights program at ECCHR. “But above all: we need to be able to hold the certification companies and the bodies that commission them liable for their actions.”

To date none of the companies involved have taken legal responsibility for the Rana Plaza catastrophe. “When disasters happen in the textile industry, producers, buyers and traders like to hide behind certificates of safety and working standards to dodge responsibility,” says Gisela Burkhardt, chairperson of FEMNET, a member of CCC. TÜV Rheinland did not adequately inspect the documentation of the building safety nor the worker’s records at Phantom Apparel Ltd. in Rana Plaza. This is shown by the investigative reports on the collapse as well as by victim statements. “If the inspections are inadequate then the certificates are not worth the paper they’re written on,” says Thomas Seibert, South Asia coordinator for medico international. “In order to restore workers’ faith in the social auditing mechanism a fundamental change in the philosophy and agenda of BSCI is necessary. Today workers consider such inspection processes a meaningless ritual,” says Saydia Gulrukh, from the Activist Anthropologist Collective.

Filed under: , ,
See also
Clean Clothes Campaign statement on five years anniversary of Tazreen Fashions fire Clean Clothes Campaign statement on five years anniversary of Tazreen Fashions fire

Five years ago today, the Tazreen Fashions factory in Bangladesh went up in flames. Over 112 ...

Bangladesh Safety Accord will continue safety work after 2018; Brands sourcing from Bangladesh should sign on Bangladesh Safety Accord will continue safety work after 2018; Brands sourcing from Bangladesh should sign on

The Accord on Fire and Building Safety in Bangladesh will continue its coordination of brands’ ...

Bangladesh Factsheet February 2015

Four years since Aswad fire compensation by brands can no longer wait Four years since Aswad fire compensation by brands can no longer wait

Today four years ago, a fire broke out in the Aswad Composite Mills textile mill in Bangladesh, ...

Statement of the Bangladesh Accord's Witness Signatories on the three-year renewal of the agreement Statement of the Bangladesh Accord's Witness Signatories on the three-year renewal of the agreement

Today, the global union federations Industriall and UNI announced agreement with brand and retailer ...

Global support for Bangladesh factory safety surpasses one million

Over one million people have signed petitions calling for brands sourcing from Bangladesh to sign ...

Textile mill fire in Bangladesh signals need for expanded safety inspections and remedy Textile mill fire in Bangladesh signals need for expanded safety inspections and remedy

A devastating fire in a Bangladesh textile mill at the beginning of this month reaffirms the need ...

European Parliament should vote for an investigation into Bangladesh labour violations European Parliament should vote for an investigation into Bangladesh labour violations

Clean Clothes Campaign is today calling on members of the European Parliament to call for a trade ...

EU should use review to push for workers' rights and freedom of association in Bangladesh EU should use review to push for workers' rights and freedom of association in Bangladesh

Tomorrow, 18 May, the third annual review of the so-called "Sustainability Compact" between ...

Four years after Rana Plaza: steps in the right direction but a lot remains to be done Four years after Rana Plaza: steps in the right direction but a lot remains to be done

On 24 April 2017 the Clean Clothes Campaign network will be remembering those killed and injured at ...

more ...